John Norris: Fundamental flaw in minimum wage debate

Applicable as of July 1, 2025: Oakworth Asset Management, LLC (“OAM”) is a registered investment adviser that is owned by Oakworth Capital Bank Inc., Member FDIC (“OCB,” or together with OAM, “Oakworth”). Please note that OCB and OAM are separate entities that provide different services. All investment adviser services including investment management and financial planning are provided by OAM. OAM only began operations on July 1, 2025. Any content that was created prior to that date is specific to OCB and not OAM and is provided for informational purposes only. The statements or opinions expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of OAM. The article was produced prior to OAM’s registration as an investment adviser and therefore was not reviewed for compliance under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. OAM believes that the prior content is appropriate because of the similarities in OAM services to OCB services. The individuals involved in the production of OCB content will also be involved in OAM services. For additional information about OAM, including its services and fees, send for the firm’s disclosure brochure using the contact information contained herein or visit advisorinfo.sec.gov.

A group of economists recently released a research paper that suggested Seattle’s increase to a $15/hour minimum wage has had a negative impact on the lowest skilled workers. It would seem the market clearing rate for unskilled labor out there is around $13/hour. Up to that level, hourly workers largely benefited from the gradated rate increases, in aggregate. Past that, the report implied the well-intended $15 minimum wage has had some ironic consequences on a decent segment of the local unskilled workforce.

Intuitively, this makes sense.

A major problem with the debate about minimum wage laws is it assumes companies pay workers for their time. They don’t. They pay them for the economic value of their labor, and time is simply a way of measuring it. We can legislate an hourly price floor all we want, but we can’t dictate the actual hourly value of individual workers. If someone is worth, say, $12/hour to an employer, the government can mandate $15/hour all it wants. That person will eventually be out of work, because no business is going to continually pay them more than they are worth.

(Read the full article as previously published in the Montgomery Advertiser on July 10th, 2017)